The high fructose corn syrup formula tested much better than either Coke or Pepsi.
The majority (88%) of tasters said that they would buy and drink this if it were Coke but that they would need to get used to it.
12% of the tasters were angry. Resenting the change, they said that they might stop drinking Coke entirely.
The surveys were actually far more positive and their results led to the decision to change to a sweeter formula. This was fine with Coca-Cola CEO Roberto Goizueta. While in charge of Coke's subsidiary in the Bahamas, he had improved sales by adjusting the drink's flavor. This success led to his belief that a change to the taste of Coke could increase profits. No one paid attention to the clue offered by that angry 12% among the tasters, a decision that would have great consequences in the months and years ahead.So, Coca-Cola management went ahead with the plan. That sweeter formulation, made to go along with the success of the sweeter Diet Coke (which had edged 7-Up out of its place as the Number 3 soft drink), became New Coke.The Introduction of New CokeApril 23, 1985, New Coke was introduced to the world at a Lincoln Center press conference in New York City. It was a day that Goizueta and the other executives that mounted the stage had high hopes for. They were about to overturn a century of tradition-the formula had changed from time to time over the years but it had never been completely changed before-and the press, with many questions provided by Pepsi, wasn't about to let them off easy.They didn't. The questions were demanding and the answers considerably less than stellar. Goizueta's attempt to describe the new flavor was ridiculed in the press as well as the industry as a whole, especially since he was one of the companies best flavor chemists. In the end, they were just happy to have it over and done with. Other events and give-aways followed and pretty soon the customers were back and sales even started to go up. In spite of the rocky start, it looked as if it was working.Up to this point, Coke seems to have done everything right. They had recognized industry trends, examined the success of their chief rival, conducted extensive market research, prepared a massive public relations and marketing effort and it all indicated that New Coke should be a big hit.What went wrong?The Angry 12%The research from Project Kansas indicated great support for the new formula, but it also registered a small but vocal opposition. In light of the overwhelming positives, this segment was ignored. That was a mistake since it indicated the possibility of a major backlash among consumers, which is precisely what happened.After early acceptance among consumers nationwide, the backlash came. Centered in the Southeast, where Coke got its start and where it still is a cultural icon, resistance to the new formula soon spread across America. Some of the highlights of this backlash include:
Chicago Tribune columnist Bob Greene's widely reprinted articles poking fun at New Coke and attacking the company's executives for changing it.
Ridicule from talk show hosts and comedians.
Fans booing New Coke ads that appeared on the scoreboard at the Houston Astrodome.
Long-time Coke drinker Fidel Castro called New Coke a "sign of American capitalist decadence."
Over 400,000 angry calls and letters received by the company. A psychiatrist hired to analyze phone calls to the company hotline reported that some people sounded like they were discussing the death of a family member.
New Coke product boycotts.
New Coke bottles being emptied into the streets of southern cities.
Customers attempted to import stocks of the original formula from overseas.
Legal action and a potential boycott from the bottlers over syrup pricing and the backlash they faced individually over New Coke.
With chaos within its consumer base and Pepsi working hard to take full advantage running ads (such as the one where a first time Pepsi drinker exclaimed "Now I know why Coke did it!"), Coca-Cola executives were in a panic trying to figure out where they went wrong. By May they were discussing the reintroduction of the original formula and when the June sales figures came out and showed a leveling off of sales, there was real fear that profits would fall. Pepsi's gains were, however, very small. The fact was that alienated customers didn't switch to Pepsi, they simply refused to buy New Coke.It didn't take long for it to become chic to hate New Coke, and the peer pressure coming from that new social aspect was devastating. The executives at Coca-Cola knew from positive letters and calls that new formula did actually have a following among consumers, but they were like Nixon's "silent majority" and said very little in the face of the loud, strenuous condemnation. According to Don Keough, the President and Chief Operating Officer at the time, he overheard the following conversation at an Atlanta country club:"Have you tried it?""Yes.""Did you like it?""Yes, but I'll be damned if I'll let Coca-Cola know that."By June 23rd, it wasn't a question of "if" they would go back to the original formula, but "when."Going Back to The Real Thing: Coca-Cola ClassicOn June 11, 1985, less than three months after the introduction of New Coke, the Coca-Cola company announced a return to the original formula. It is a reflection of the power behind the feelings of the people that Peter Jennings interrupted ABC's regularly scheduled programming to announce the news and Senator David Pryor brought attention to it on the Floor of the Senate, referring to the reversal as "a meaningful moment in U.S. history."New Coke continued as Coca-Cola while the original formula-now based on high fructose corn syrup instead of sugar cane-was called Coca-Cola Classic. By 1992, the new formula was marketed as Coca-Cola II and after a while it was taken off the shelves here in the United States (it lasted in certain areas around Chicago until 2002). It has, however, a following in certain foreign markets. In 2006, Coke II was still selling in Micronesia, American Samoa and French-speaking Quebec, Canada.Lessons from New Coke"There is a twist to this story, which will please every humanist and will probably keep Harvard professors puzzled for years," said Keough at that July 11th press conference. "The simple fact is that all the time and money and skill poured into consumer research on the new Coca-Cola could not measure or reveal the deep and abiding emotional attachment to original Coca-Cola felt by so many people."Coke spent over $4 million and came close to losing their business altogether just to learn the lessons of New Coke, all of which can be summed up in the advice of Polonius to his son, Laertes, in Act I, Scene III of Shakespeare's Hamlet:This above all: to thine ownself be true,And it must follow, as the night the day,Thou canst not then be false to any man.For a century, Coca-Cola had developed its following on being "The Real Thing." Yet, when they felt the pinch from Pepsi-a pinch that had more to do with its merger with the Frito-Lay company and the benefits of the new distribution channels and shelf-space agreements that came with it than direct soft drink competition-their executives didn't stand on the quality of their product, they decided to change it. They were not true to themselves, true to their customers, true to their brand or true to their product. Perhaps, they thought that they were being true to their stockholders, but in the end it really doesn't matter what they thought they were doing or being. What matters is the fact that they had the most recognizable product in the world and they decided to change it to make it more like the competition.When you take your products or your services and make them more like your competition, what does that accomplish? If it is a long-standing brand, it leads to trouble with your market. However, it leads to more than that. It removes any real difference between you and your competitors. In the days of New Coke, I switched between New Coke and Pepsi without a thought since to me there was no discernable difference between them. I no longer cared, the only question I had was, "which one is on sale?"Your brand is important to you. It is your name in the marketplace, your reputation among your customers and it represents what sets you apart. These things make it valuable and deserving of your attention and protection. In their panic and zeal, the executives at Coca-Cola forgot that and it cost them a lot of money and even more prestige. How much would it cost you if you were to forget?To thine ownself be true!
Charles Cooper is the Web Editor and blogger for http://www.gowithabc.com, the Web site for America's Best Companies. He is also a staff writer for America's Best: The Magazine for Small
Related Posts :
- Ladies Print Long Jersey Skirt
- Chris King Stainless Steel Cog 16t New
- Dave Keon Signed Hockey Puck In Gold Autographed Nhl Pucks
- Tektrum 30w Solar Panel Blocking Diode Cable 2m Long Cable And Clamps Battery Charger Kit For Rv Home Boat
- Wally Post 1960 Topps Signed Autograph Psa Dna Certified Mlb Slabbed Autographed Cards
- Marslg Hydroponic Mylar Grow Tent 3 X3 Nontoxic Hydro Cabinetmars363678
- Signed Shea Mcclellin Photo 2012 8x10 W Coa 4 Autographed Nfl Photos
- Autographed Fred Biletnikoff Jersey 25 White Stat Jsa Certified Autographed Nfl Jerseys
- Panasonic Lumix Dmclz5s 6mp Digital Camera With 6x Image Stabilized Zoom
- Kasco Marine Robustaire Aquatic Aeration System Ra1pm For Ponds To 1 5 Surface Acres 120 Volts Includes Post
- Gwen Stefani 24kt Gold Record Ltd Edition Display Free Priority Shipping
- Outdoor Decor Gazebo Indoor Outdoor Window Panels 50 By 96 Orange
- 18 1960 S New York Yankees Signed 8x10 Photo Lopez Lyttle Stafford Linz Carmel Autographed Mlb Photos
- Sedona Audio Pier
- Jim Mcmahon Autographed Hand Signed Chicago Bears 8x10 Photo Free Shipping Black Custom Frame
- Autographed Mchale Photograph 8x10 S85839 Psa Dna Certified Autographed Nba Photos
- K9 Ballistics Orthopedic Round Tuff Dog Bed Black Medium 36
- Allan Houston Autographed Hand Signed Detroit Pistons 8x10 Photo Free Shipping Black Custom Frame
- Michael Douglas Autographed 8x10 Photo Falling Down Image 1 Brief Case
- Marcus Allen Signed Oakland Raiders Jersey With Photograph
- Velo Transit Men S Compact Waterproof Messenger Bicycle Backpack
- 100 Brushed Nickel Ball Valve Showerhead Shut Offpack Of 2
- Edressit 2013 New Fitted Red Prom Dress 00131002
- Norpro Gripez Stainlesssteel Composter Keeper With 2pc Replacement Filter Set
- D5318 Dell D5318 Dell D5318
- Vaxcel Lighting Cppdu170 Black Walnut
- Mark Bavaro Autographed Signed 1988 Topps Card 83369471 Psa Dna Certified Signed Nfl Football Cards
- Richard Petty Signed 16x20 Photo Ironmen W Ripken Custom Framed
- Audioquest Class X Video Cable Rca Plugs 4 5m 14 76
- Ron Greshner Autographed New York Rangers 8x10 Photo Black Custom Frame
- Chief Mount Chief Adj Pipe 18 To 24
- Reaching Summit
- King Autographed Picture With The S Speech Inscription Autographed Nba Photos
- Gojo 975 Orange Creme Pumice Hand Cleaner 4 5 Lbs
- Visual Chemistry Specimens
- Bob Lilly Dallas Cowboys Nfl Bulk Lot Of 8x10 Photographs Close Up Quantity Of 25
- Ricoh Vf1 Removable External Viewfinder For Gx100 Gx200 Digital Cameras
- Sam Siegel Signed To Sammy Davis Jr Hey Jewboy Book Psa Dna Certified Autographed Nfl Magazines
- Autographed Hardaway Photo Jr Michigan Wolverines 8x10 W Coa 2 Autographed Nba Photos
- Autographed Irving Photo 8x10 Framed Matted Jsa Certified Autographed Nba Photos
- Goal Zero 12401 Nomad 13 5m Solar Panel
- Vacudome Food Storage Unit
- Rocks Off Groovy Chick Vibe Cosmic Orange
- Flotec Multistage Booster Pump 660 Gph 1 2 Hp 3 4in Model Fp5712
- Grace Digital Gditw3usbe Victoria Tunewriter Iii 7in1 Stereo Entertainment Center Black
- Police Men S Pl13398js 61 Rewind Gray Dial Stainlesssteel Black Leather Watch
- Larry Johnson Autographed Hand Signed Kansas City Chiefs 8x10 Photo
- Toyota Corolla Customfit Allweather Rubber Floor Mats 4 Pc Set Black 2009 09 2010 10 2011 11
- Green Toile Portable Crib Bedding
- Ryan Callahan New York Rangers Nhl Framed And Matted Photo 2012 Portrait Plus 16x20 Photo
- Yamaha As2000bl Natural Sound Stereo Amplifier Black
- Boston Celtics Nba Framed And Matted Photo All Time Greats Composite 20x24 Photo
- Joint Max Triple Strength Eq Granules For Horses 180 Doses 2 88kg
- Klein D200048ins 8inch Insulated Highleverage Diagonalcutting Pliersangled Head
- Jason Terry Autographed Hand Signed 16x20 Photo Hawks Psa Dna S76696
- Genuine Gm Parts 10431948 Passenger Side Taillight Assembly
- Rob Blake Signed Colorado Avalanche White Ccm Replica Jersey
- Step2 Girl S Big Splash Waterpark Pink Purple
- Sam Bradford Autographed St Louis Rams 8x10 Photo Black Custom Frame
- Europro Shark Navigator Lightweight Pet Hair Canister Vacuum Uv300
- White Industries Eric S Eccentric Eno Single Speed Rear Hub Silver Polish 135 Mm 32h
- Bushwacker Toyota Extendafender Flare Set Of 4
- Nero 12 Platinum
- Waring Wto150 4slice Toaster Oven With Builtin 2slice Toaster
- Roush 401345 Hood Scoop For Mustang 05
- Optex Wireless 2000 Annunciator System
- Hohner Inc M2011bxla Marine Band Thunderbird Harmonica A
- Mariners At Athletics 4052010 Opening Day Game Used Second Base
- Joe Sakic Signed Photo 8x10 Black Custom Frame 2x Stanley Cup Champion 2012 Hall Of Famer Autographed Nhl
- Rodial Chin Neck Lift1 7 Oz
- Exide Xmc31 Megacycle Agm200 Sealed Maintenance Free Agm Marine Battery
- Portmanteau No Lxiii
- Ted Lyons Signed Baseball Loa Official Macphail American League Hof Psa Dna Certified Autographed Baseballs
- Broan 63w White
- Parmenide Red Green Blue
- Nuforce Cubespeakerred Portable Speaker With Headphone Amplifier And Audiophilegrade Usb Dac Red
- 1in Foot Valve Brass
- Signed Bergeron Picture Brad Marchand Singing At Parade W 8x10 Autographed Nhl Photos
- Xikar Xi1 Cigar Cutter Room 101 The Fu
- 39x40 Tri Weaver Rail Red Green Blue Illuminated Scope
- Signed Couture Photo 8x10 Go Autographed Nhl Photos
- Summer Light
- Jet 708476 Model Jjp12hh 12inch Planer Jointer With Helical Cutterhead
- Invacare Ivc Tracer Iv Wheelchair 22 450 Lbs With Removable Desk Arms And Footrestblue
- Bla Bla Kids Coco Girl Doll
- Spider Monkey 1
- Kraus Fvs1800ch Decus Single Lever Vessel Faucet Chrome
- New Guess W15072l3 Two Tone Steel Bracelet Women S Watch
- Dewalt Dw266 6 5amp Variablespeed Reversing Depthsensitive Teks Screwdriver
- Halo Wars Mega Bloks Set 96805 Unsc Rocket Warthog Artic White
- Weathertech Custom Fit Cargo Liners For Ford Escape Black
- Dwight Howard Autographed 8x10 Photo Psa Dna S43751
- Cadillac Williams Autographed Mini Helmet Carnell Jsa Coa Autographed Nfl Mini Helmets
- Don Shula Autographed Hand Signed Miami Dolphins Sb Vii Celebration 8x10 Photo Custom Framed Perfect
- Greenlee 730bb13 8 Standard Round Knockout Punch Unit 13 8inch
- Arthur Court Rooster Paper Towel Holder
- At T Dect 6 0 Digital Four Handset Cordless Telephone With Answering System And Caller Id Sl82418
- Forces Of Valor German Jagdpanther New Package And Paint
- Moen T6103an Kingsley Twohandle Low Arc Bathroom Faucet Antique Nickel Not Ca Vt Compliant Valve Not Included
- Heavy Industry Series N J
No comments:
Post a Comment